Share something that Dumas says about theory and provide a short reaction to it. Note: this can be about theory in general or something about the specific theory he worked with and it can come from the chapter or from the short "Personal Reflection" that followed.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2/12 Dumas' Theorizing Redistribution and Recognition in Urban Educational research: "How do we Get Dictionaries at Cleveland?"
Share something that Dumas says about theory and provide a short reaction to it. Note: this can be about theory in general or something abou...
-
After reading Parker, please react to the piece by: 1. Note something that you agree with or that you learned. 2. Share something that you d...
-
Share something that Dumas says about theory and provide a short reaction to it. Note: this can be about theory in general or something abou...
-
Do you see any connections between the three readings for this week? Put another way, why might I have selected the Youth Sports and Marshma...
Kiara Crawley:
ReplyDeleteEarly on in the chapter, Dumas stated theorizing helps us figure out what policies and remedies are "substantively" and "strategically" worth pursuing (p. 82). Although he was specifically referencing equitable practices for and in urban schools, this perspective is applicable to a variety of fields/research. As scholars with unique experiences, we naturally develop our own perspectives and as we grow as researchers, we learn to connect our perspectives to findings from other researchers to help substantiate our claims. In this respect, theory gives credence to what others may just view as opinion or thought and allows us to make educated claims for what we believe are the best course of action for solutions that promote change.
This idea is further supported in his reflection at the end of the chapter. Dumas speaks to the fact that we develop our theories early on--simply be experiencing life within our own cultural and socio-political identities. However, he emphasizes theory's transformational power when he integrated the political philosophies of Nancy Fraser into his work. He stated, "Fraser's work on the politics of redistribution and recognition, which directly takes up the question of how we theorize remedies for social injustice...provides a potentially more meaningful use of theory than simply running our mouths," (p. 107).
Further in his reflection
Dumas uses Fraser’s (1995/2000) framework of redistribution versus recognition in social justice agendas. Dumas theorizes that there is a neoliberal argument against redistributing economic opportunities in a district and uses Hollin’s argument as an example. Hollins does not agree with ‘taxing’ schools in the north and redistributing funds to the underperforming schools in the south. Dumas argues that this ‘taxing’ would go against the neoliberalist idea that competition amongst schools (i.e. fighting for the most funding) is an effective approach to school reform. Reformers often value competition amongst schools more than they value equal economic distribution.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, Dumas’ theory is an example of utilizing a ‘sociological imagination’ (Mills, 1959) on an educational issue. The social justice agenda to fight for recognition– defined by Dumas as different social groups “efforts to seek redress for forms of cultural disregard, disrespect, and low social esteem” (p. 82)– is actually distracting groups from fighting for economic redistribution. Dumas’ ability to see beyond the benefits of group recognition, and see how it is a ‘distraction’ from gaining more funding, is a great example of looking at a micro-issue with a macro-level lens. Dumas saw how broader society values competition much more than equal economic distribution and that this value system is having deleterious effects on educational equality. The author's use of theory and the use of a sociological imagination is a good example of seeing educational issues through a sociological lens. I’m beginning to understand that when educational issues are seen through a sociological lens, one can get to the core reason for the issue and better theorize a solution.
I really liked his discussion of affirmative remedies vs transformative remedies. I didn't really have a grasp on the difference until the paragraph where he quoted Fraser, saying we "destabilize existing status differentiations and change everyone's self-identity" (p96). His description of critical multiculturalism as using market forces to create new identities for esteemed and devalued groups wasn't terribly clear to me, but it sounds like a good idea. I wish he had talked more about nonreformist reforms because, yes, I'm used to affirmative remedies, things that help a need right now rather than the status-quo busting transformative remedies that could help in the long term (but don't because they're not enacted). I would love to have some concrete suggestions for how to improve things now AND work toward long-term, radical solutions.
ReplyDeleteI am with you on wanting to read more about "nonreformist reforms." Before I read your comment, I actually went back to that section (p. 97 and 98) and reread it a few times to make sure I understood it clearly. The words radical and persistent stood out to me. I read it as - Don't just make demands for what your students need right now in this moment and quiet back down when you get it. Be persistent in your continued demands for equity. Be an unrelenting advocate for justice. Get loud. Maybe I'm wrong, though?
DeleteI thought the Dumas' reflection highlighted the very personal nature of his development and use of critical theory in his work. Kiara pointed this out as well - that we develop the background of "theory" early on in life and our identities and experiences help use make shape of these theories.
ReplyDeleteI thought this case in particular with the school board meeting and dictionaries provided a great example of the issue between redistribution vs. recognition. I think (speaking from experience in secondary ed over the past 5 years since covid and huge cultural shifts) we have made some progress in recognition of inequities in education and more educators are willing to have those conversations, but the problem still exists (obviously). Dumas noted that a critical approach to teacher professionalism (p. 98) could be the key to working toward solutions to this problem. I'm interested in hearing more about what others think of this as a potential "solution".
Also, one thing I wrote down and now don't remember why or where it came from was the phrase "achievement gap" and how in many situations it places the blame on students and their inabilities to achieve when they don't have the resources to "achieve" at the same level as other students. This bugged me!
p. 82 "And the achievement gap can be interpreted as an opportunity gap... and as the result of low academic expectations of students of color based on their racial/ethnic identities (Fine et al., 2004)."
DeleteOops! That was me responding. I forgot to put my name in.
DeleteI also really appreciated Dumas' personal reflection at the end of the chapter. His three lessons about engaging in theory really stuck with me. I resonated with his idea that "no one theory will ever do" (p. 104) because when I reflect on theories I've seen in academic writing, I often remember bits and pieces that I enjoy, but rarely do I recall one singular, complete theory. This gives me hope as someone who is looking to find a theory/some theories to eventually guide, frame, and support my dissertation work. The idea that I don't have to commit to one theory is a refreshing thought.
ReplyDeleteAlso as a general reflection to this chapter, I thought it was helpful how Dumas clarified how he was using theory to support his thoughts as he was doing it throughout the chapter.
Dumas defines theory as a way to systematically understand what is happening in the world. He acknowledges the intellectual contributions of scholars but highlights that the foundation and passion for his theoretical knowledge stem from two key sources: lessons from his mother on surviving the experience of schooling as a Black boy, and growing up listening in on adult conversations (p. 104).
ReplyDeletePersonal experiences influence us all, making theory relatable to everyone, regardless of their background. Understanding theory can sometimes feel overwhelming (at least for me), especially when it challenges us to think critically about complex issues. Reading about how Dumas draws from his own experiences to make sense of theory was really insightful for me. It reminded me that I, too, should draw from my own foundational experiences to better engage with and understand theory. We often get so caught up in academic language and jargon that we forget to connect with our humanity, which is where true understanding begins.
In Dumas’ personal reflection, he referenced critical theory as one of the first theories he learned naturally from his mother. I think that would apply to anyone as part of our minds develops during the nurturing stage as we venture out into the world. However, if we hone in on critical race theory, is what many of us in “minoritized” communities face early on before knowing what it is called. Our parents teach us to navigate our environments without them when we enter classrooms and interact with other communities and races. We think that it should not be like that, we should all walk into the world and class on equal footing, as referenced in the chapter. Unfortunately, it does not work that way. It can be argued that class plays a role. Still, once historical factors that advertently and inadvertently caused inequalities and inequities amongst minority groups become apparent of the divide in race and class. Desegregation was supposed to be the fix. Then, it turned into re-zoning and redlining, which continued to perpetuate the segregation and inequalities of allocation of funding for public schools.
ReplyDeleteAnother example of critical race theory taught to us as children was understanding that we learn and pass the test as instructed by our teachers and school systems, yet being taught lessons of history, culture, and civics according to our home communities. Understanding that questioning the teacher about the coursework can be seen as being defiant and disruptive to the class. We learned about our place in society and played the game accordingly. In which we still do.
Dumas’ ideas about theory as a tool for challenging systems align with my research of leveraging students' languages. By including Frasers' ideas on redistribution and recognition, Dumas would say theory can help ensure multilingual students receive the resources and opportunities while validating their languages and cultures. This approach disrupts exclusive practices and pushes for a more inclusive, equitable education.
ReplyDeleteAnomalously, Dr. Michael Dumas drew from critical social and political theory to analyze educational inequities, by focusing on redistribution and recognition. I appreciated Dumas' work because it introduced me to the merge between political theory and social theory. Dumas focused on critiquing policies surrounding redistribution. Dumas highlighted political philosopher, Nancy Fraser’s (1995 & 2000) work, that brought to light the "cultural and political-economic roots of social justice." This led to the thought of "non-reformist reforms." I appreciate how Dumas and Fraser are using theory to mobilize, not only stop at theorizing. Dumas' work led me to believe that through theory, actionable solutions can occur.
ReplyDelete