After reading Parker, please react to the piece by:
1. Note something that you agree with or that you learned.
2. Share something that you disagree with or that you possibly take issue with.
3. Ask a question related to or inspire by the reading.
After reading Parker, please react to the piece by:
1. Note something that you agree with or that you learned.
2. Share something that you disagree with or that you possibly take issue with.
3. Ask a question related to or inspire by the reading.
Share something that Dumas says about theory and provide a short reaction to it. Note: this can be about theory in general or something abou...
1. I agree that we should be teaching truth-finding. I focus on statistical literacy in my undergrad liberal arts courses, and I talk a lot about evaluating the graphs/data that they see to determine if the data really supports the story that's being told.
ReplyDelete2. I don't agree with the middle paragraph on page 4. Parents don't want both sides, they want either/or. My parents literally sent me to an (almost) all white private school in the next county because "the education was better" (more like their own beliefs).
3. How do we get away from standpoint theory? I've been told for a while, even in this program, I feel, that everyone has their own reality based on their identity, which means we can't really get at the powerful knowledge Parker describes.
Kiara Crawley:
ReplyDelete1. Parker ended the article with, "schools need to do what they can to teach the truth and
methods of finding it, and why the curriculum field needs to help," (p. 6); and I absolutely agree. Teaching to pass state assessments to meet specific metrics should not be priority. There is a place in the majority of the curriculum to include powerful knowledge and include unique voice.
2. Although I agree there is a need to do so, I do not agree with Parker's statement that this is not a quixotic endeavor. Unfortunately, those same followers that agree to disseminate brazen lies and misinformation to intentionally and those that blindly accept it, are also teachers and administrators. I find this most troubling for development of younger students. For example, my son attends a school that is majority Caucasian (faculty, administration and student body). Last year, while in first grade, he brought home an activity he completed in class where after participating in a lesson about her, he colored a picture of Ella Fitzgerald. To my surprise, he colored her white and so did every student in his class except for one. When I asked if he knew she "looked like us," he said no! Their teacher made sure to conceal Ella Fitzgerald's true identity. Do you know how deliberate you have to be to do that? At home, I had to provide my own lesson of Fitgerald, including pictures and videos, and had my son recolor her picture. Considering the historical significance of her fame and talent during a period where black scholars, musicians and entrepreneurs created their own thriving community despite the overwhelming thwart of discrimination and segregation, it was paramount I reveal her true identity to help instill a level of confidence but most importantly reveal truth to my son.
3. This incident leads me to ask, how can we ensure "powerful knowledge" is actually included if the instructors personally agree with the practice of deliberately sharing misinformation. How can we ensure sustained correction of this behavior if our nation's leadership can casually get away with it?
I disagree with Parker’s sentiment that teaching skills like ‘sourcing, corroboration, and voice’ are “doable” based on the assumption that they “follow the existing contours of classroom pedagogy” and that “the resources to enact them are at hand” (p. 3). I wonder when’s the last time Parker has observed a Common Core culture, high-stake-test-loving, public school classroom? Does curriculum in the era of accountability allow for students to learn skills like ‘sourcing, corroboration, and voice’?
ReplyDeleteParker summarized Young and Muller's assertion that the purpose of schooling is to “provide students access to knowledge of the reliable kind”-- that reliable knowledge has the same “emancipatory potential” as critical pedagogy because it “establishes a common standard of truth” (p. 4). This is such an interesting concept that I certainly agree with! A very common critique of schools is that the curriculum does not provide students enough opportunities to critically debate and discuss and yet Parker takes a different avenue. He critiques critical pedagogy and argues instead that curriculum should emphasize everyday knowledge. This sets a foundation for students to be able to become critical thinkers.
While I agree that we have an issue as society with distinguishing fact from "fiction", I have trouble with Parker's assertion that "sourcing and corroboration" are the path forward to "powerful knowledge" and "Truth". If parsed out more, I'm sure he would consider source bias or motive and corroboration for misinformation. There are plenty of "resources" available to corroborate the idea that the Earth is flat (for example) and confirmation bias is a huge concern I see in our society and schooling presently.
ReplyDeleteI do like that he indicated that discourse is essential to "find truth". Setting students up to become critical thinkers is a foundation of education and students should have the agency to make judgements about their views and the views of others, instead of hearing things that simply confirm what they already think or believe (or what they hear at home).
I wonder, are we doing enough / how are we ensuring that students continue to question "reliable knowledge" in a productive way?
1. I agree with how Parker concludes (p. 6) with Arendt's (2005) sentiments about how because of civic lying, some people have become so cynical, that they have "an absolute refusal to believe in the truth of anything, no matter how well this truth may be established."
ReplyDelete2. I am not sure to what extent I agree with the expressed idea that certain types of knowledge are objective (p. 5). Who gets to decide which types of knowledge are objective?
3. Thinking again about the conclusion, how can educators best work with students who refuse to believe in the truth of anything?
I disagree with Walter Parker’s idea that a shared reality based on common facts is essential for democracy. While a shared understanding is important, it risks marginalizing diverse cultural perspectives. I value students' various forms of knowledge, which may not align with the dominant narrative.
ReplyDeleteParker emphasizes "disciplinary knowledge" as vital for democracy, but this often reflects Western frameworks. He writes, "disciplinary knowledge is what sustains a democracy," but this ignores the rich, practical wisdom found in indigenous knowledge systems, which offer valuable insights into sustainability and community.
Democracy thrives on pluralism, and a single shared reality may stifle important contributions from marginalized groups. True democracy respects diverse ways of knowing and being.
I agree with Parker’s (2024) statement that “many citizens have lost the distinction not only between truth and fiction but between gossip and journalism” (p. 1). The current reading wars have been exacerbated by misinformation in the media, particularly so with Emily Hanford’s podcast, Sold A Story. The podcast mixes factual reporting with emotional appeals, and from my perspective, largely tells only one side of the story, which makes it hard to tell the difference between accurate journalism and stories loosely based on factual information. The content of her podcast snowballed into a significant change in legislation in Virginia mandating scripted curricula, which Hanford later denounced in bonus episodes of the podcast. Though Hanford advocated for an increased focus on phonics and a shift away from balanced literacy, she has contributed (ironically) to increased commercialization of literacy curricula. The irony lies in the fact that her podcast criticizes figures like Fountas and Pinnell for profiting off balanced literacy.
ReplyDeleteI think Parker’s claim that these proposals are practical and doable is somewhat presumptuous, particularly when it comes to voice. Though I believe wholeheartedly that students benefit from structured opportunities to express themselves, the law often limits how and when this can happen. Governor Glenn Youngkin has restricted the teaching of certain topics (e.g. race, gender) and emphasized parental control of the curriculum.
How can we as educators effectively encourage/promote questioning and/or fact-checking within the constraints of policies that limit the teaching of certain topics?
I agree that, as educators, we have a civic duty to teach the truth. However, what truly is the truth? That is where the complications lie. My truth or my interpretation of the truth of history and other disciplines can be designed and redesigned to tell the whole truth, part truth or not the truth based upon influences of the government, society, and religion.
ReplyDeleteIt is unfortunate that shared knowledge and truth have seemingly become more divisive instead of consensus, as mentioned in the article because there are many things that are truth that are at risk of being erased or disregarded.
Is it truly possible for American Education to be all on the same page?
Chineen S:
ReplyDelete1) One thing I really agreed with was Parker's point about teaching students how to find the truth specifically skills like evaluating evidence and checking sources. In math, students need to back up their answers and think critically abut whether their solutions make sense. It's not just about numbers; its about reasoning, which ties into his whole idea of truth-seeking.
2) I get Parker's focus on curriculum and teaching specific content, but I think he's a little hard on the "critical" approaches. Understanding how things like privilege or inequality affect access to education is huge. It's not just about what we teach, it's about making sure all students actually have the chance to learn that content in the first place. So, I feel like those approaches add something important, even if they don't always focus on curriculum development.
3) Im curious about how Parker's ideas about teaching "powerful knowledge" and truth-seeking connect to math education? Can we bring ideas like justice and democracy into math classrooms? It feels like those things are mostly talked about in history or social studies, but I think math has a role too.
1) Parker opens with a very strong stance, naming that the issue that American citizens face is that, "They lack a shared standard of truth for distinguishing facts from falsehoods" (Parker, p. 1). I deeply agree with this statement, as I believe there are many realities, values and belief systems that exists, but unity and harmony is far from the aim that we've taken.
ReplyDelete2) Parker speaks from a lens that believes we've had the distinction between "truth and fiction" or "gossip and journalism" before our current president, Donald Trump. As much progress as we've made in society, I'd push back and state that propaganda, the search for truth and Truth, the delineation between truth and fiction have always been a tension, especially in education. Freedom Schools and the establishment of integration is an example of truth established by those who appreciate truth and then unidentified, dishonored and sieged by policy makers who hold value to fiction and gossip of their own accord.
3. I would love to ask Parker, "In a just society, what is your example of shared reality and how can we reach a shared reality?"
3. I would also ask Parker, "What is your definition of truth?"
ReplyDelete